I am panicking, and I find it helps to write out the panic; once I see it in writing, I switch into “What if someone else were saying these same things?” and I get more reasonable. (“Why doesn’t this person just…?” Ha.)
Here is what set me off: Edward (he’s 8) had a playdate at our house. I couldn’t tell if it went well or not, if I should be interfering less or more in their disagreements, if Edward’s social skills were normal or advanced or sorely lacking, if the other boy was typical or a concern. I came out of the experience feeling wrung out and like I don’t know how to do anything, and also HATING having to deal with the kids’ social lives. I don’t even like to deal with my OWN social life, but THEIRS?? I have to manage OTHER PEOPLE’S??
And it’s not just a matter of “I hate to do it,” it’s that I don’t know how to do it. There’s this precarious feeling of I COULD BE WRECKING EVERYTHING BY NOT KNOWING WHAT I’M DOING. I could be getting my kids involved with people who are bad for them, and I could be encouraging them to act in ways that attract more of that. I could be over-interfering/under-interfering. When I THINK I’m teaching social skills, I could ACTUALLY be passing on my social anxieties/mistakes, not only genetically but by example and training. I don’t know if that’s even avoidable; it might just be one of the things my kids will have to work through, the way we all have to work through things we get from our parents.
This one single playdate has spiraled me off into a whole “How am I supposed to get these kids safely to adulthood?” panic attack. It’s the “peer contact/influence and social life in general” version of that attack, and it has combined tidily with the “THERE IS TOO MUCH TO TEACH THEM AND I’M FAILING TO COVER IT ALL” version. Furthermore, the things about the other boy that made me wonder if he might be “a concern” reminded me strongly of Henry, so then I’m panicking about THAT, TOO. And then of course there are my own interactions with the other boy’s mother to fret about, both current (“Was I too weird? I shouldn’t have referred to drinking”) and future (“What if she calls and tries to arrange another playdate but Edward doesn’t want to? What if she knows her boy is A Concern, and she’s hoping these playdates will help?”).
I’m remembering two things from my own social life as a child, but I don’t know how specific those were to me and my particular social preferences. The first is that it did NO GOOD for my parents/teachers to set up playdates with kids they thought I’d like. And it didn’t work to try to make people be friends with a misfit: learning to seek out other misfits was something I had to figure out myself, and it was a very useful life tool: by the time I was in high school, I knew not to chase popular kids, and I knew there were good friends and good alliances to be found among the unpopular kids. INVALUABLE. But perhaps I didn’t have to figure that out? Perhaps that’s something we COULD teach kids? I don’t know. And there can also be danger in the misfit crowd: it’s not like “being a misfit” automatically equals “being an awesome person who has been rejected by the mainstream for stupid and superficial reasons.”
The second thing I’m remembering is that as a teenager I was very annoyed any time my mom made my social life “about her.” I didn’t see what my social choices had to do with my parents AT ALL, GAH MOM. Now I see it from more a Mom Perspective and it looks different to me: of COURSE we wonder if it’s our fault when our kids struggle or make poor choices. Certainly SOCIETY gives us the side-eye about it. But their social lives ARE theirs. Their friend choices WILL affect their lives—but THEY will choose those friends. I can try to expose them to Nice Kids all I want, but I don’t really know which kids are Nice, and I don’t really know which ones will be good friend choices and which ones won’t be. As I child I had some dicey-seeming friends from dicey families, and some of them turned out dicey—and some of them were excellent. I also had some Nice friends from Nice families who turned out to be bad choices and not at all Nice.
Here’s another thing: some of my childhood experiences with Bad Choice friends are what TAUGHT ME WHAT A BAD CHOICE FRIEND WAS. From the outside, in the parent role, it can look like “This is a bad choice for my child”—and yet it’s the very thing that kept me from some bad choices later on (“Ick, this is reminding me of that bad friend; I think I’ll back away”), when the stakes were higher. But it didn’t have to go that way, and how could anyone tell ahead of time whether it would be a lesson or an influence?
AND, this is yet another of those situations where if we WANT to blame/credit our parents, we can blame/credit them no matter what they did: “My parents kept forcing me into social situations I wasn’t comfortable with, so I learned to deal with them!” / “My parents kept forcing me into social situations I wasn’t comfortable with, so I learned to avoid social stuff and also that my parents wanted to be someone other than who I was.” Or “My parents never gave me experience with social situations, so I never learned to deal with them” / “My parents never forced me, so I had time and space to learn and become comfortable in my own way.” And of course each set of parents will have their OWN experiences to work with: “I was shy and my parents really helped me by setting up playdates, so I’ll do the same for my kids”—which leads to the next generation saying “My parents set up playdates and it was the worst thing ever, so I won’t do that to my kids.” SIGH WHY IS IT ALL SO HARD