You have seen the bad, now it is time to vote on five that didn’t come out so bad. I’ve invested as much tooth enamel as I’m willing to, so there won’t be any more sessions and these are the final five options:

Option One
(l to r: William, Elizabeth, Henry, Rob, Edward)
The good:
- Great of William, great of Rob.
- Fine of Elizabeth and Edward.
- Acceptable of Henry.
- The older four all look happy.
The bad:
- Only one child is looking at the camera.
- It’s hard to see in a smallish photo, but Elizabeth looks strained because she’s laughing with her teeth clenched.
- Also, Elizabeth is holding a marker.
- It’s acceptable of Henry, but it would be nice for it to be GREAT of Henry, since this is his first Christmas card photo.
- Edward has his hand in his mouth, and he’s squinting.
- I didn’t dress them specially for the picture, so they’re just in whatever they happened to be wearing.

Option Two
(l to r: Edward, Rob, Henry, William, Elizabeth)
The good:
- I like the arrangement and think it’s interesting to look at.
- It’s fine of Edward, Rob, and Elizabeth.
- It’s cute of Henry.
- Everyone’s looking at the camera.
- They’re wearing clothes I deliberately selected.
The bad:
- The clothes I deliberately selected don’t work. The red shirts blend into the chair. The orange shirts match in a jarring way: “Why do these two children match?” The brown dress is a different shade of brown than the brown in the shirts.
- It’s bad of William.
- Edward’s hand is in his mouth and he’s pointing.

Option Three
(l to r: Edward, Elizabeth, Rob, William, Henry)
The good:
- The arrangement is a little jumbled, but I find it pleasing to look at.
- It’s great of Edward and Rob.
- It’s good of Elizabeth.
- It’s acceptable of William.
- Everyone but Henry is looking at the camera.
The bad:
- The clothes still don’t work.
- Henry is posed weirdly and has his hands in front of his face and his legs splayed out and his jeans are pulled up funny.
- William is poking Henry.

Option Four
(l to r: Henry, William, Elizabeth, Rob, Edward)
The good:
- I think this kind of arrangement works way better than the ones in the chair, where children were spilling out of the confines.
- I chose the clothes deliberately, and this time I think they work: not as matchy as I might like, but not clashing or drawing attention.
- It’s terrific of Henry.
- It’s very good of William, Elizabeth, and Edward.
- It’s acceptable of Rob.
- It’s cute to have the older boys holding the younger boys, and the Elizabeth on her own in the middle.
The bad:
- They are looking in three different directions.
- William’s smile is kind of forced.
- Rob looks kind of weird. And I like the older children to look as cute as possible, since younger children are pretty cute even if they’re not at their cutest.
- Elizabeth isn’t as cute as she could be, and last year she was the one who got sacrificed in a photo that was great of everyone else, so this year I’d like her to be really cute.
- It’s on our BED. Is that okay? To have OUR BED in the Christmas card photo?

Option Five
(l to r: William, Henry, Elizabeth, Edward, Rob)
The good:
- It’s terrific of Henry and Edward, and Edward was SO DIFFICULT to get good pictures of. He kept ducking at the last second. At one point I gripped his upper arm in a manner not compatible with the spirit of Christmas.
- Pleasing symmetry: older boys tilted very slightly out, younger boys tilted in, girl perfectly straight in the middle.
- Elizabeth’s pose is typical of her, and it’s cute the way her toes are pointed in and her hands are folded. She’s not smiling, but I think her expression is cute anyway. So earnest.
- It’s good of William.
- Henry’s “NEW!” shirt is showing.
- William is holding Henry’s foot in a cute way.
- Rob and Edward look cuddly, and I like how Rob’s hands are positioned. He looks like such a big brother. You’d never guess that Edward kept slamming the back of his head into Rob’s chest and chin.
- EVERY SINGLE CHILD is looking at the camera. Isn’t that one of the signs of the apocalypse?
The bad:
- It’s not great of Rob. His teeth ARE prominent, but they’re not THAT prominent. And his smile isn’t characteristic. It’s not BAD of him, but it’s not as cute as he is. Compare to Option One, which is more typical of him.
- It is, as I say, on our bed. Which, meh?
I think there are two kinds of votes that are useful: own-conclusion votes, and reactive votes. So first I think you should choose your favorite, and vote for it without reading any comments. THEN, if you have sufficient time and interest, read the comments and see if it changes your opinion at all–and if it does, say so. My mom and I find that sometimes we each choose a favorite, but then when we hear the other person’s favorite we change our minds–or become stronger in our convictions.






