I took a month to get around to buying an Instead Softcup, and then another month to get up the nerve to try it. Now I have tried it, I’m done trying it, and I’m ready to give a report.
I’d like to start by praising the instructions. Here’s how they start:
“Remember the first few times you used tampons or wore contact lenses? Well, reusable Softcup also takes a little time to learn to use correctly and comfortably. At first, it may seem awkward to either insert or remove reusable Softcup…that’s OK, most women experience that.”
I found that tremendously encouraging and heartening.
I bought the reusable version (each one can be rinsed and reused for the length of one period), but there’s also a disposable version. Since they have to be changed at least every 12 hours, I figured the 2-pack of reusables would last two full periods, but the 14-pack of disposables would last at most 7 days—and more likely less than 5 days. It’s approximately the same price per box, so that makes the reusables a much better deal—especially because even with a disposable I imagine you’d still need to rinse it out and not just drop it in the trash as-is, lest the family freak out.
My own personal situation, for comparison going into this, is that I’ve had only c-sections and I don’t like the feeling of tampons. I usually use reusable cloth pads, and it was a little hurdle to get used to rinsing those out but now I don’t mind it.
So. Putting the Softcup in. You sit down on the toilet to do this. You pinch the round Softcup edge so it looks like a number 8. Then you slide it in flat and level like a cookie sheet into the oven. You heard me. Cookie sheet. You don’t insert it UP and IN like a tampon, you insert it ACROSS and DOWN like…nothing else, ever. This made no sense to me until I tried it, but now I want to look again at the anatomical drawings in the gynecologist’s office.
For a few minutes after I put it in, I felt a slight crampy feeling, which worried me—but that feeling went away, and then I didn’t feel anything. I was triumphant: NOW I had a tampon-like thing that was NOT A TAMPON!
Alas: within a couple of hours, I’d justified the prudent use of a back-up pad. I was a little discouraged, because the cup was nowhere near full and it had been nowhere near 12 hours, but I thought I probably just hadn’t done it right somehow, so I rinsed it (slight hurdle, but okay—I could get used to that, as with rinsing pads) and tried it again. The same thing happened again.
That’s when I gave up. Not because of the leaking per se, though that was discouraging, but because of something I haven’t discussed yet: removal. I don’t know what I was imagining, but I guess something…tidier. And maybe I would have gotten used to it and started doing a better job at it, and maybe I had it in wrong which would explain both the leaking and the messy removal, and maybe the leaking was the only reason the removal was messy—but sometimes you just find your own personal line, and I’d found mine.
Not only was removal quite an unpleasant feeling to both my hand and my Interior Regions, but also to my psyche: you have to REACH IN and FIND and then GRIP and PULL. And the circle is NO LONGER PINCHED NARROW as it was for insertion, and it is SURPRISINGLY STURDY PLASTIC. And then there I was, sitting, with one hand bloodied and holding something that needed immediate rinsing before reinserting, and I still needed to clean myself up as well. Goodness, what to do? Wipe with one hand while holding the other hand aloft, trying not to spill; then stand, go to the sink, rinse out the Softcup, wash hands; then go back, sit down, wipe again, put the Softcup back in? What a complicated mess! And impossible to do in, say, a work/public restroom. Luckily I was at home, but it was quite a procedure even so.
So my review sounds very negative, doesn’t it? I tried it, I didn’t like it, I’m not going to use it. BUT! I think it’s like cloth pads: some people might try them and say “UG, they feel like DIAPERS, I HATE them! And I’m not willing to RINSE and LAUNDER them, what a complicated mess!!” Whereas I find them cozy and I don’t mind the fuss. So it’s just a matter of finding the tool that works for your tolerances. And my experience with the Softcup told me that it wasn’t right for me (though I’m saving the second one that came in the box, just in case I feel like trying again later), but it also told me that it seemed to have good potential for a different sort of person: it seemed well made, and the instructions were very good, and overall it seemed GOOD. Just not for ME. (Probably. Maybe later.)






