FitBit

It feels a little as if EVERYONE has a FitBit, so perhaps this post is unnecessary. But if you DON’T have one and you’re wondering what it’s LIKE, then I will tell you in time for you to add it to your wish list.

I have the clip-on FitBit (as opposed to the bracelet style). It’s the least expensive FitBit option and it looks like this:

(photo from Amazon.com)

(photo from Amazon.com)

(photo from Amazon.com)

(photo from Amazon.com)

I chose the green one. It was an agonizing decision.

You may notice it looks different in its two pictures: this is because it’s shown with and without its little protective case (the case has the clip on it). I think the case makes it look even prettier, because it’s a complementary shade of green that takes it from “is this green, or is this yellow?” to “green—a yellowish green, but it’s green.”

You can clip it to your bra strap, or you can clip to your pocket. I tried it both ways, and I much preferred the pocket; my mother prefers to clip hers to her bra, but this does make for an amusing sight if she’s trying to check her steps while we’re out in public. If you clip it to your pocket, you’re supposed to clip it to the INSIDE of your pocket: that way if it falls out of its little clip-case, it drops safely into your pocket. It also means that all you see from the outside is the little one-inch-by-1/4-inch stripe of clip, rather than the whole FitBit. This is something to take into account, though, before ordering one of the brighter colors: the green would be very noticeable against my jeans if I didn’t always wear long shirts.

I’ve had the FitBit for just over 2 months now. I wondered if I would even like it, but I DO. In fact, I really, REALLY like it. And you know I am not an Exercise Person.

Here is what I like: it uses the kind of methods that are effective on me to encourage me to do the exercise I feel like I ought to be doing. I like the feeling of having someone monitor my good behavior approvingly: if I walk to my parents’ house instead of driving, someone NOTICES and makes a little SMILEY FACE about it. It’s why I like the Wii Fit, too: I like that someone is KEEPING TRACK. I get CREDIT. And I don’t know why it would be motivating to have a computer keep track uncaringly of steps or minutes or whatever, BUT IT IS. The downside is the same as for most such situations: it increases the feeling that if the monitoring stops, there’s no point behaving. If the FitBit stopped working one day and I knew it wasn’t recording my steps, my motivation would PLUMMET. Buuuuuuuuut….”plummeted” is near my USUAL level of motivation, so not much lost, and lots gained.

Here is what the dashboard (on the computer) looks like:

(screen shot from FitBit.com)

(screen shot from FitBit.com)

When I first set it up, I changed the step goal to 2000 because I didn’t have any idea how many steps I might already be doing, and I didn’t want to get discouraged right off the bat. (The miles and active-minutes goals are also adjustable.) After awhile, I raised the step goal to 5,000, and then to 7,000, then to 10,000.

You get badges (little pictures on your dashboard) for meeting milestones: your first 5,000 steps in a single day; your first 5 miles; etc. They’d be more fun if there were more of them: after meeting all the early goals, the later goals feel so unlikely. Also, I don’t like the feeling it gives me that NOTHING IS EVER GOOD ENOUGH. “You went 30,000 steps in a single day? Great! NOW DO MORE.” Also-also, I want to see all my badges in little rows like on a Girl Scouts vest, not just the one they consider “top.”

I like that it differentiates among the intensities of different kinds of walking. Like, if I am strolling around Target, leaning on the cart handle indolently while sipping a coffee and barely lifting my feet, those steps are orange (“light”); but if I am out on a walk, those steps are yellow (“moderate”) and/or green (“very”). The colors can be a little tricky because each line’s color represents the steps done in that 15-minute period. So you can do 5 minutes of fast walking and 10 minutes of sitting down and end up with an orange or yellow line, no green showing—and yet the Very Active Minutes dial will still count those 5 minutes. (Someone who is Very Active Indeed may resent the level the FitBit considers Very Active: if I walk just over 2 miles/hour, it registers as Very Active.)

There was a calorie tile, too, but I took it out because I found it perplexing/upsetting/unhelpful, and because my latest attempt at improving overall health is trying not to get discouraged and give up when healthful moderate exercise doesn’t seem to result in being willowy and underweight, and trying to focus on exercise being good for overall health ANYway, especially now that I am in my Elder Years. But it’s interesting because it tracks ALL estimated calorie usage, including while you’re asleep, not just “exercise calories,” and so maybe I will use it later on.

You can see over to the right of the dashboard screen that you can be friends with people and see their steps, and it ranks you in order and declares a weekly winner. But I think I would find that kind of competition discouraging and/or upsetting and/or annoying. I MIGHT add Paul, if he were to get a FitBit—but I can picture getting annoyed and unfriending him.

I worried that it would be a pain to set up, but it was not. I wish I could remember how much personal information it asked for, because that’s the kind of thing I like to know before setting up something online. I notice that my weekly email from them is addressed to “Kristen Surname Initial,” so presumably it doesn’t make you put in a full/real name. I think it’s first and last name (though I used an initial) and user name and password; also I think height and weight. Then you plug a little nubbin into a USB port on your computer, and you hold up the FitBit, and it syncs up. Thereafter, it automatically syncs every time you get near your computer. (There are separate instructions for setting it up with a smartphone or tablet.) My mom almost never checks on her computer, and always looks at the FitBit itself; I almost never look at the FitBit itself, but I have the FitBit window always open in a tab on my computer.

The email level is nice. FitBit emails once a week to tell you your previous week’s summary: how many total steps, how many total miles, how many average steps/miles per day, highest/lowest daily steps/miles. It also nags you to set up the sleep tracker, but the type of device I have doesn’t DO sleep, I don’t think. FitBit also sends an email each time you earn a badge.

So! The FitBit is one of those devices that seemed very expensive to me for something I wasn’t even sure I would LIKE or USE—but now that I have it, if it broke I would buy a new one WITHIN THE HOUR and I would pay extra for overnight shipping. It’s made a significant difference in how I feel about exercise and how willing I am to do it. If I have to park far away, I think, “Yay, more steps!” If I JUST came upstairs and realize I need something else from downstairs, I think, “Well, I’ll get more steps.” If I’m at 8,000 steps for a day, I’ll think, “Hm, maybe I’ll go for a little walk!”

It takes me from “Very Unmotivated to Exercise” to “Just the Right Amount of Motivated.” That is, I feel a little uncomfortable if I don’t meet the step goal, but I don’t change my life in negative ways (finking out on other plans, staying up past bedtime, forcing myself to exercise even when I’m sick or hurt) in order to meet it. I’m not sure I would recommend it for anyone who feels they might get a little obsessive about it, or who finds themselves prone to “Nothing is ever enough” feelings.

This would also not be ideal for someone who gets a lot of physical activity in non-step-taking ways: I imagine it would be quite frustrating to lift weights all afternoon and then have a frowny-face on your FitBit as if you’d been eating Reese’s Peanut Butter Trees and reading People magazine.

22 thoughts on “FitBit

  1. Linda

    I have the Fitbit One and I LOVE IT. I reviewed it here: http://indigogirl.typepad.com/linda/2013/10/fitbit.html

    It tracks my sleep (how accurately? I don’t know but I love data!) and it sends me an email when my battery is low. Such excellent customer service! I, too, wish there were more badges to earn/display.

    The little wireless thing that plugs into your computer is called a dongle. I had trouble at first and was giggling madly as the fitbit website tried to help me troubleshoot my dongle insertion.

    Reply
  2. Sally

    Thanks for the info! I’ve been debating asking for either the FitBit or the Jawbone Up for Christmas. Anyone have the Up?

    Reply
    1. Gina

      Sally – I have the Up band and I LOVE it! I have it set to buzz me when i am inactive for a certain period of time, so it reminds me to get of my butt. I also LOVE the sleep monitor. Particularly the smart alarm – I have felt much better rested in the mornings since using it to wake p vs a regular alarm.

      Reply
  3. Ann Wyse

    I’d never heard of this, so I’m glad you posted about it. ;-) (I’m blaming my lack of knowledge about anything current on the baby.)

    Reply
  4. Leeann

    I’m glad you posted this too. I had asked for one for Christmas but felt uncomfortable about it bc of price and also bc I am hardly a super healthy person so ::guilt::

    Now I feel more confident in my asking!

    Reply
  5. el-e-e

    oh, FINE, I’m now properly motivated to start wearing mine (the wristband) again. Huff.
    (I did like it, when I wore it, except that i always had my steps goal set WAY too high and thus I felt like a failure most days. Maybe if I start at 2.000 I could achieve that and then try more, like you did.)
    And I totally agree w/you about the Calories tile. Too confusing.

    I love the sleep data and loved Linda’s post about that, as well. :)

    Reply
  6. mrspooley

    Thank you for this review. I have seen the fitbit but have been on the fence about it. Now I’m adding it to my wish list. ;)

    Reply
  7. JCF

    I have the Zip (same one you do), and I love it for all the same reasons. In fact, I’ve had it for about 3 months, and I’ve lost 13 pounds (I’ve made some adjustments to improving my eating, but no major overhaul). It motivates me to take the long way home from walking my son to school; walk to the grocery store, rather than drive, if I’m just picking up a few things; if I’ve got some downtime, I might run up and down the stairs a few times. I’m definitely motivated by the fact that my extra effort counts, even if it is only to a little computer.

    Reply
  8. Melissa

    I love when you do reviews because you tell me such helpful things. I might be asking for one for Christmas as well!

    Reply
  9. Peyton

    So, I’m assuming it’s a hyper fancy pedometer rather than a GPS tracker—if so, how does it deal with ambient motion? I’ve never been able to use a pedometer because, for instance, I jiggle my legs all the time when I’m sitting and it would screw with my step-count.

    Reply
    1. Swistle Post author

      Me too! I used to have a pedometer, but it didn’t work out because it counted “steps” when I was rocking in a rocking recliner! NO GOOD. I don’t know how this one does it, but it doesn’t seem to have that issue. I tried jiggling my leg rapidly, and it didn’t record any steps.

      Reply
  10. Jodie

    I love love love the emails telling me the battery is low. I have learned a few things in my 11 months with the fit bit zip that you didn’t mention:
    1) if it breaks–email them–you may be able to get a new one at no cost.
    2) if you do some sort of non-steppy activity you can log it on the site and it will increase your very active minutes and calories. I use it with the food log and nothing is more motivating than knowing you get extra calories if you walk more.
    3) if you forget to wear it and you did something like say run (or walk or whatever) and you log it–it will add steps!!!

    Reply
  11. Tessie

    Yesssssssssss!! Healthkick post!!!!

    I love the idea of getting credit and also I think the FitBit-type deals help teach you what kinds of activities really make you feel better and which don’t, which is something most people don’t notice on their own.

    The friend thing though…SHUDDER. I cannot deal with competition re: fitness which is why I’ve never tried CrossFit even though it’s in theory for a fitness freak such as myself.

    Reply
    1. Swistle Post author

      Oh, good question! I don’t know, but the FitBit.com site might have something about that in the FAQs. My GUESS, though, is no: I just pedaled my legs rapidly while sitting in a chair, and the step-count didn’t change.

      Reply
  12. PJ

    I didn’t realize you had a fitbit. I just got one am and am so delighted with it. I took my children skating and IT COUNTED MY STEPS while skating!! Very pleased by this fitbit credit. I guess my kids will get to go skating again this year.

    Reply
  13. Teej

    How did you get 30,000 steps in a day? The most I have ever gotten was 26000, and that was the day we were at Epcot from 9am to 9pm. I realize that somebody running a marathon or something else extreme would get 25,000+ steps…but how in a normalish day? (Maybe you did run a marathon??)

    Reply
    1. Swistle Post author

      It was not a normalish day: I was writing posts and watching a movie while on a treadmill. And I was very sorry afterward!

      Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.