Absolute Clothing Failure

I need a mildly dressy outfit for an upcoming restaurant situation, and I hate clothes-shopping. I was shopping online at Old Navy for other things (I need longer sweatpants—the ones I’ve been wearing are capri-length, and my full-length ones are too small), and saw a bunch of new arrivals that looked really good to me AND they were on sale. I bought this outfit:

loose high-waisted brown plaid trousers that look comfy but elegant, and a snug-fitting cream polo shirt with a cute keyhole neckline

(image from OldNavy.com)

The reviews for the pants were so good! And you can’t tell from that little picture, but they’re a cool classy autumnal plaid:

(image from OldNavy.com)

After I placed the order, I realized that several of the reviews had been from teachers saying these were such good teaching pants. I further realized that on my frame, the pants were not going to look coolly slouchy and elegant like they did on the model, and in fact I was probably going to look like a teacher, and that that would not be the right look for the restaurant. But I figured they’d be good for whatever my next job would be. Maybe I will be a substitute teacher, or a receptionist, and they will be perfect for that! Also, I look cute in polo shirts and keyhole necklines, so at least I’d have the shirt to wear with something else if the pants didn’t work out. And the shirt was available in Tall, so I would not have to accidentally peep my midriff like the poor model!

Then I ordered this bell-sleeved lace cardigan, figuring it would be good for dressying up some of my less-dressy clothes; maybe it would work with the pants, or with one of my skirts, or I could wear it over one of my frumpy shapeless dresses to give it some shape/style:

long-sleeved wine-colored lace cardigan, snug fitting with a medium-deep neckline and bell sleeves

(image from OldNavy.com)

And oh! This shirt/blouse would be perfect with the two skirts I have that don’t go with anything, and maybe also with the pants if the polo doesn’t work out! I bought it in two colors, wine and black:

snug-fitting scoop-neck wine-colored blouse with a ruffle trim around the neckline

(image from OldNavy.com)

While I was at it, I got another pair of jeans, because I hate all my jeans, and these look like the ones I used to have that I didn’t hate as much, and so I wore them until they unfortunately wore out:

normal jeans except they have a seam down the front of each leg

(image from OldNavy.com)

 

I was really excited about this order! And it was a disaster. I tried on everything tonight, and it was the kind of try-on session where you go into it thinking “It’s about whether the clothes work for my body, not the other way around!,” and you come out of it thinking “Sure, for other people, but in this case the problem is clearly my body. And also my haircut, my glasses, and my posture.”

The elegant slouchy plaid pants were shapeless, bunchy, unflattering, and several inches too long. They felt too big, but not in a way that ordering a size smaller would fix.

The polo—I don’t know how even a size 2 model made that look anything less than frumpy. I even tried it on a second time, thinking it COULDN’T have been that bad, but it was. I looked like those photos of moms in the ’70s smoking cigarettes and having bad haircuts and being depressed.

The lace cardigan was frumpy and also was not a cardigan (it didn’t claim to be one; I’d inadvertently assumed it opened up the front); and I didn’t look at the fabric content but it was astonishingly HOT: I thought I was having a stress hot-flash, but no, it was the cardigan. (I looked it up just now: 97% polyester, 3% spandex.) Also, I don’t know if this will make sense, but it didn’t look right with my glasses. Actually, a LOT of dressy clothes feel to me like they don’t look right with glasses.

The ruffle-neck blouses made me look like my grandmother on her frumpiest day. I could not believe how badly they fit and how they emphasized everything I would want to de-emphasize, while fully failing to emphasize anything I have going for me.

And the jeans were no worse than any of the other jeans I already have and don’t like, except that the pockets were like three inches deep. ALL PANTS POCKETS must be deep enough for a PHONE, and that is the RULE.

And then, just to add to the disaster, the boring comfy sweatpants I bought for walking (not pictured, because they were too boring), which DO NOT HAVE TO LOOK FASHIONABLE, also looked frumpy and baggy and made me feel bad. I do not CARE what I look like on my walks!! But these sweatpants looked bad enough that they MADE me care. They might have just been too big, but TOO LATE, THEY ARE PART OF THE FAILURE.

 

Oh, I should take this moment to recommend the non-Old-Navy capri-length sweatpants I’ve been wearing, because I DO feel cute in those, AND I have just noticed they come in a full-length version, so I’m going to order those and return the Old Navy ones.

navy blue capri-length sweatpants with a cute white stripe up the side of the leg

(image from Amazon.com)

I bought these when I was going to physical therapy for my knee and wanted something to wear that was not pajama bottoms (though I also did feel free to wear pajama bottoms). When I wear them now for my morning walks, I feel cute and sporty. And they have pockets that can hold a phone—not generously, but the phone does not fall out. They have a working drawstring; I have tied a knot on each end, because otherwise one or the other disappears within the drawstring tunnel. For sizing: I am currently wearing an 18/20 (non-W) in jeans and I have these in an XXL and they are at the upper limit of perfect: not baggy or roomy at all, but the snugness looks right for workout apparel; I bought them when I was wearing more like a 16 and they were also perfect at that size but, as you’d imagine, a somewhat less-fitted perfect fit.

Talking about these cute capri sweatpants is making me feel a little better. THEY look cute on me! Maybe I will also find restaurant clothes that look cute on me.

But on the other hand, when I needed a dress for one of Paul’s work events a few years ago, I went shopping with a fashionable friend and we went to like eight different stores and I tried on like 50 dresses and dressy outfits, and only one was even remotely okay, and now it’s too small, and also in my memory I looked silly. So. I mean, that’s why I tried pants this time! And a blouse for the skirts I have that are okay! But FAILURE, FAILURE, FAILURE! I look terrible in all clothes!!!

Perhaps I will wear the cute capri sweatpants. Oh! I can wear them with my unexpectedly-flattering champagne-sequined tank-top!

30 thoughts on “Absolute Clothing Failure”

    1. A

      I second this, I love their dresses. The long ones with the crossover back are so comfortable and I can wear them without a bra. In the winter I put a long sleeve shirt over them and leggings under them. They are mostly cotton with just enough stretch to feel very nice.

      Reply ↓
  1. Ariana

    Swistle! I have those exact capri sweatpants and I love them also! I keep meaning to buy a second pair.

    I am also struggling mightily with clothes of late. So, sympathy.

    Reply ↓
    1. Swistle Post author

      Ooo, what color do you have / what color might you add?? I have the navy, and I am thinking of adding one of the greens, maybe the wine red. I’m a little bit tempted by the yellow and purple, but I think I’d feel conspicuous in a way I don’t like to feel on walks. For my new full-length pair, I’m getting navy.

      Reply ↓
      1. RubyTheBee

        I’m not the original commenter, but I just ordered them in dusty rose! If I like them I might get black as well, and/or light purple.

        Reply ↓
  2. Mary Kate

    I feel your pain and I am right there with you. I was feeling extremely frumpy and was seriously buying into the idea that I just wasn’t a fashionista. But then I realized that even if I wasn’t fashionable that I still wanted to feel comfortable in my clothes. So I have been on the hunt for flattering clothes, which had been frustrating but fruitful.

    After checking Reddit and looking at various
    non-ai generated lists, I learned that the weird indent that pants/tight clothing unflattering cling to is called a hip dip and there are ways to deal with it. https://intecore-pt.com/heard-of-hip-dips/

    One way is to look for pants/clothes made with ponte fabric. The materials and the way the fabric is made smooths things out without clinging to the wrong parts of your body.
    https://zelouffabrics.com/blogs/news/the-ultimate-guide-to-ponte-fabric?srsltid=AU7gw4XLrLSX_l158f6C0z0I5UFUInjiQ0IJsIRfyUYV

    I used this knowledge to buy a bunch of pants/tops trying to find some good options. While I did return a lot, I have found some things that I like see.

    One pair of pants that were highly rated and also worked for me our Old Navy’s pixie pants: https://oldnavy.gap.com/browse/product.do?pid=551152072&vid=REGULAR&searchText=womens%20pixie%20pants#pdp-page-content

    I did end up sizing up so keep that in mind. My regular size was fine but felt a little tight at my hip dip. The larger side allowed the fabric to be a little looser which is much more flattering.

    Since I have started this quest and have been slowly collecting flattering clothes and donating the rest, I feel so much better about myself. My hope is that if enough of us choose comfortable (flattering) clothes then maybe clothing companies will make more of them.

    Reply ↓
  3. Jaida

    gah. solidarity, sister. my perimenopausal body has settled directly between two sizes. since i am simply not willing to be pinched/squeezed, everything just looks schlumpy. thank heavens i am not dressing for public appearances, but even so it would be nice to feel cute once in awhile. sigh.

    Reply ↓
  4. Meg

    I recently bought a flattering black shirt/blouse with small white flowers on it, which buttons down the front. I leave the top two buttons undone so it’s basically a V-neck without showing any cleavage, and I wear it as a smart-casual work top. I wear a lot of plain black and this is a little bit fancier. It fits me well, doesn’t set me off in a sensory way, and I feel like I look nice in it.

    On the same day I bought a brown top which is basically just a slightly fancier t-shirt, a sort of crinkly material. It’s a round neck instead of a V, and Vs definitely suit my body type better but this one isn’t too bad. Brown is an OK colour on me but it’s not great. I feel like I look bearable in it. I don’t *hate* the feel of it, but the material makes me twitchy.

    I get compliments on the latter. Have never had one on the former.

    Oh, and I struggle like anything to find clothes that I a) am comfortable in and b) feel like I look OK in for whatever scenario and c) feel like I can put together in an outfit. I will never understand clothes or clothes shopping.

    Reply ↓
  5. Nicole MacPherson

    Oh, NO. That is the worst, and I’m sorry. How demoralizing. I would have thought that lacy non-cardigan would have been super cute, as I was reading this I thought “that will be perfect for an evening out” and UGH. Why must things be like this. I’m sorry.

    Reply ↓
  6. Dana

    I highly highly recommend the Vinted app. Everything is so cheap, and the shipping is cheap. If you dont mind second hand clothes, stuff is even cheaper!
    I love Lands End Starfish Pull On pants. They last foreverrrr and they can be dressed up or down.
    (i say this with love but its prob time to move past Old Navy. The quality just isnt there anymore)

    Reply ↓
  7. Erin

    I agree that it likely is time to move past Old Navy. It’s been my go-to since college and worked well these past few years when my daughter was a teen and I’d pop in with her and get some things for myself too. I admit the price is great, but the quality has declined and things often don’t fit right.

    Last spring, I needed a dress for an event and a friend suggested a Nordstrom personal shopping appointment. I was concerned about the cost but the appointment is free and I realized I could set a budget for an outfit. Holy cow! The difference in how quality clothes fit, feel and look was astonishing to me. Even a tank top the salesperson brought me to try under a cardigan fit so beautifully! I left with a dress for the event, two pairs of work pants and a couple of tops. I probably could have gotten a dozen things at Old Navy for that price. But these things fit and wash perfectly and I will have them for years.

    Yes, it required getting out there initially, being honest with the salesperson and being a bit uncomfortable during the process. But now I can go back on my own, I know the brands in the store that fit my budget and I have accepted that I will pay more for fewer items but those items will fit comfortably and look good. Having a few great outfits on hand is worth it to me.

    But do get the sweatpants at Old Navy!! So cute!!!!

    Reply ↓
    1. Kristina

      This is great advice. Better to get quality pieces that fit, and work together, than piecemeal that you don’t wear. My husband hates shopping and has twice done Nordstrom personal shopping. It makes shopping tolerable and he only does it once every 5-6 years.

      Reply ↓
      1. Annabeth

        I did a personal shopping thing like this just for jeans and it was brilliant. I just have tried on 30 pairs but trying them on ins lovely fitting room while a very understanding lady went to fetch things she thought I might like in sizes that would probably fit was SUCH a different experience to normal shopping or online shopping. Do it for the blog post if you don’t believe us 😘 and take your capri joggers to show something that looks and feels good.

        Reply ↓
  8. Cece

    One thing that I think tends to make a difference is to pay really close attention to the fabric of what I’m buying. Polyester, be gone! Pure wool, I love you but you do not love my skin and I cannot live with the itch.

    At this stage I am willing to buy cotton/linen and accept the ironing/steaming that will inevitably follow because I feel like at least they’ll feel nice on my skin and not cling in weird places.

    Reply ↓
  9. Cara

    Can you find capri jeans in the same cut as the sweatpants? They usually have a bit of spandex, so the fabric really isn’t that far off. Worn with your sequined tank top and cute flats they would absolutely be restaurant clothes where I live.

    Reply ↓
  10. Anna

    Polyester is a scourge. I say if you have sweatpants that work for you, wear them with your cute top. At a restaurant your top is all anyone sees 90% of the time.

    Reply ↓
  11. Taylor

    Coming here to recommend Zuri dresses. https://www.shopzuri.com/collections/standard-dress-new. They are not cheap but they have a good range of sizes, fun colors, are flattering on just about every body type and can be dressed up or down. (I am not associated in any way with this company–I just love the dresses). I usually get one on sale every couple of years and now have a collection going. I’m a US 14 or so and wear a large.

    Reply ↓
  12. Gillian W Egan

    Highly recommend these. I have been many sizes in my life and have tried them in a few – I go with dark/jewel toned versions. I get compliments every time, on both styles. They are not well made by any means, but they’re cheap enough who cares. I also do love Quince for nicer stuff, and if you hate giving Jeff Bezos his forty seventh yacht. But that’s more – gotta try it to find out.

    https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0C3H921Q2?ref_=ppx_hzsearch_conn_dt_b_fed_asin_title_11&th=1&psc=1

    https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0CLRNX9FC?ref_=ppx_hzsearch_conn_dt_b_fed_asin_title_14&th=1&psc=1

    Reply ↓
  13. Kate

    Oh I hear you. (All the way from Australia). I am tall and used to be slim but am not so slim anymore, and I cannot find suitable new clothes ANYWHERE.
    So pretty much the only places I shop now is op/thrift shops and TK Maxx (TJ Maxx to you).
    Even with a limitless budget in expensive department stores, I can easily find suitable pants but no tops. Everything is too wide and/or too short and/or linen and/or brown.
    Fortunately I love op shopping so I just roll with that.

    Reply ↓
  14. Elizabeth Kiker

    Oh I HATE those moments where the 10 FANCY, AWESOME clothes you bought online and EVERY SINGLE ONE — I MEAN EVERY. SINGLE. ONE. Makes you look like an insane frump. And then, like you said, you are like — no, I will try them on again — and they look WORSE?! WHY? HOW? That has happened to me on and off in my life and I just return them all and then try again. But oh I hate it when it happens.

    Reply ↓
  15. Allison McCaskill

    It’s NOT YOU, Old Navy is SO WEIRD. I have a couple of pieces from there that I adore and have worn for ten years. But last summer I ordered FIVE sundresses, and they were all horrible in uniquely different and hideous ways, and my friend had the exact same experience. Some of their clothing is made for aliens with non-human proportions. And how DOES some clothing just automatically make your hair and glasses terrible, when they were fine thirty seconds ago? I blame the patriarchy, obvi.

    Reply ↓
  16. Maria

    I have had four kids in six years (pretty much exactly – numbed 1 turned 6 nine days before numbed 4 was born) and am currently 6 months postpartum. Pants are not my friend. I have resigned myself to the fact that I am in a dresses and skirts phase of life as I find them to be much more forgiving to my ever changing body and the places where weight has settled. Somehow I am WAY fitter and stronger than I was seven years ago and yet wear a larger size in everything. All this to say that I have had MANY sessions of entering on clothes and feeling like the most frumpy person on the planet many times. Solidarity.

    Reply ↓
    1. Maria

      Why did my stupid phone autocorrect number to numbed not once but twice?!?! I AM a decent speller and literate, I swear.

      Reply ↓
  17. mcw

    Ugh. I feel your pain. My go to lately for semi-dressy outfits has been a blazer (love a sweater blazer! can wear it to a lot of occasssions), button down shirt or a tee with a cute detail & necklace, and pants with wide waist band/ stretch in the middle (have found some at Toad&Co that work well for me)! The blazer makes me feel professional/ dressed up and de-emphasizes any muffin top, my spot that makes me most self-consious!

    Reply ↓
  18. Melissa H

    Thank you to the commenters here as I have an upcoming event and nothing to wear and based on something said above I just booked an appointment with a Nordstroms stylist. WAY outside my comfort zone but given the nature of the event and my inability to choose clothing I think it’s the right call!

    Reply ↓
  19. JMV

    They are not inexpensive, but they last forever and can be worn dressed up or dressed down. On Eileen Fisher’s website, put in F3TK1. It is a washable crepe pant. They can be rolled up and tossed in a suitcase and come out wrinkle-free. I wore mine at least weekly for 2+ years and they just got recycled. Eileen Fisher can look baggy chic on Asian women, but they can also look like normal comfy pants on slightly round middle age women. They are pull on pants and are so comfy I don’t want to claw them off at the end of a business meeting. Im comfortable splurging on good pair of black pants that can be used in all situations. I personally never buy EF tops cause they look boxy on me.

    Reply ↓
  20. Terry

    I’m sorry that happened, how demoralizing. It’s not you at all, those just aren’t the right clothes for your body. I got so frustrated feeling frumpy in my clothes and not knowing how to shop my way out of it that I decided to study personal style systems. I’m not suggesting you should do that, but it has given me a language and understanding of how to dress my body and how to shop for clothes that I never would have understood otherwise. I can quickly determine which clothes would look awful on me and why and which might be okay or good before trying them on.

    Maybe consider finding a different go-to brand than Old Navy, since they just don’t seem to cut it. I like the idea of the Nordstrom shopping assistant others have mentioned. Another idea is to thrift at either a local secondhand store like a Goodwill boutique or online such as Thredup. Thredup makes it so convenient to order, try on, and return things you don’t like for a refund that I just can’t go back to paying store prices. They will also sell your items you are ready to part with and you get a small cut.

    Reply ↓

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.